Scholarly vs. General/Popular Periodicals

Periodicals are defined as publications that appear on a regular basis and can refer to newspapers, journals, magazines or other serials.  As college students your papers are expected to include research from scholarly journal literature.  Magazine and newspaper articles found in popular or general periodicals are more often used for background information and for very current topics. While there are times that it is not clear which type a periodical may be, the following chart should be helpful.

Scholarly Journal

Popular/General Magazine

Often will have the word “journal” in the title

May have the word “journal,” such as ladies Home Journal, but this is rare

Lengthy, and will provide footnotes and a bibliography

Rarely footnoted, with little or no documentation

Written by an expert in the field

Written by a staff member of the publication or freelance author

Not illustrated, unless with graphs or charts

Glossy pictures, covers, and often heavily illustrated

Concerned with academic study and/or research – articles are refereed or peer-reviewed

 

Goal is to entertain the reader

Usually contains technical jargon and terminology of the field

Very simple language, written for general readers

Few advertisements

Numerous ads

 

 

Examples:

Examples:

Journal of Experimental Psychology

Psychology Today

The Journal of Southern History

Time

 

The electronic periodical databases subscribed to by the library index hundreds of periodicals and include a huge number of full-text articles.  Under the search box are boxes to help limit the search – one that includes the option to find only scholarly (refereed) journal articles.

Limit the current search (optional)

image to articles with text
image to refereed publications